Variegated thistle control

Page last updated: Monday, 8 February 2016 - 7:43am

Please note: This content may be out of date and is currently under review.

Control methods for variegated thistle (Silybum marianum) a declared pest in Western Australia.

Information about this pest can be found on the variegated thistle: declared pest page.

Chemical requirements

When using any agricultural chemicals please ensure that you always follow instructions on the label and any permit. Users of agricultural chemical products must always strictly comply with the directions on the label and the conditions of any permit. To view permits or product labels go to the Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority website.

Control options

Chemical control options can be found below. For other methods of control please refer to the variegated thistle: what you should know page.

Chemical control options

Recommended herbicides

Winter - spring: 2,4-D LV ester; 2,4-D amine

Actively growing: Glyphosate; Basta®

Pre-cabbage stage of weed: Metsulfuron + MCPA; MCPA

Up to four leaf stage of weed: Jaguar®

Plants up to six leaf: Bromoxynil + MCPA

Seedlings: Paraquat + diquat

Rosettes prior to stem elongation: Clopyralid + MCPA

Prior to flowering: Dicamba

At flowering: Paraquat; Glyphosate + 2,4-D

Herbicide: 2,4-D ester (Group I) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

  1. 600g/L 2,4-D ester
  2. 680g/L 2,4-D ester

Rates of dilution for spot spraying

1:660 - 1:330

Amount of product/10L water

  1. 10-35mL
  2. 10-30mL

Rate of product/ha

1.5–3mL

Wetting agent dilution

1:600

Time of application

Winter-spring, as early as possible after emergence

Remarks

Use lower rates for seedlings, increasing as plants run up to flower. A split application of 2L/ha in early winter followed by 2L/ha in spring is often more effective. High concentrations may be needed when spot spraying under difficult climatic conditions.

More information and other control methods

  • Grub individual plants. Unsprayed large infestations can be slashed at early flowering stage to reduce seeding.
  • Note: The 2,4-D treatment can not be used within 10km of a commercial vineyard or tomato garden (see Restricted Spraying Regulations).

Herbicide: 2,4-D amine (Group I) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

  1. 500g/L 2,4-D amine
  2. 625g/L

Rates of dilution for spot spraying

1:500-1:200

Amount of product/10L water

  1. 20-50mL
  2. 16–40mL

Rate of product/ha

  1. 2-5L
  2. 1.6–4L

Wetting agent dilution

1:600

Time of application

Winter-spring, as early as possible after emergence

Remarks

Use lower rates for seedlings, increasing as plants run up to flower. A split application of 2L/ha in early winter followed by 2L/ha in spring is often more effective. High concentrations may be needed when spot spraying under difficult conditions.

More information and other control methods

  • 'Spray-graze' in pastures using 500-750mL/ha. MCPA at 1L/ha can also be used for ‘spray-grazing’.
  • A spraying permit required if treating within 5km of a commercial vineyard or tomato garden.

Herbicide: Glyphosate (Group M) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

360, 450, 490 and 540g/L and 680g/kg glyphosate

Other concentrations are available

Amount of product/10L water

  • 75-100mL glyphosate 360g/L
  • 60-80mL glyphosate 450g/L
  • 55-75mL glyphosate 490g/L
  • 50-65mL glyphosate 540g/L
  • 40-50g glyphosate 680g/kg

Adjust the rate if using another concentration of glyphosate

Rate of product/ha

  • 2-3L glyphosate 360g/L
  • 1.6-2.4L glyphosate 450g/L
  • 1.5-2.2L glyphosate 490g/L
  • 1.3-2.0L glyphosate 540g/L
  • 1-1.6kg glyphosate 680g/kg

Adjust the rate if using another concentration of glyphosate

Time of application

Actively growing. Do not graze before treating. Use higher rates on plants greater than 12cm diameter.

More information and other control methods

Where shallow water or treatment is adjacent to drains or creeks Roundup Biactive or Razor are the preferred glyphosate treatments. Glyphosate (trimesium = Touchdown) is also registered. Glyphosate will remove all the vegetation and may not be a desirable treatment on country prone to soil erosion.

Herbicide: Metsulfuron (Group B) + MCPA (Group I)

Active ingredient

600g/kg metsulfuron methyl + 500g/L MCPA

Other concentrations are available

Rate of product/ha

5g + 0.84-1.1L MCPA (LVE*) *Low volatile ester

Time of application

  • In wheat and barley: pre-cabbage stage of weed.
  • In cereals: apply from five leaf stage to commencement of flag leaf (Z15-37).

Remarks

Do not apply to oats

More information and other control methods

Triasulfuron (Logran) @ 30g/ha also recommended as a pre-emergent treatment in wheat

Herbicide: MCPA (Group I) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

500g/L MCPA as dimethyl-amine salt

Amount of product/10L water

15mL

Rate of product/ha

1.5L

Wetting agent dilution

1:400

Time of application

Apply pre-cabbage stage

Remarks

Extreme cold or drought will reduce effectiveness

More information and other control methods

  • Rain within six hours may reduce control. Treatment is softer on subterranean clovers than 2,4-D.
  • A spraying permit required if treating within 5km of a commercial vineyard or tomato garden.

Herbicide: Dicamba (Group I) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

200 and 500g/L and 700g/kg dicamba

Amount of product/10L water

15mL dicamba 500g/L

Rate of product/ha

1.2L dicamba 500g/L

Wetting agent dilution

1:400

Time of application

Prior to flowering

Remarks

  • Non-crop situations
  • Clovers will not tolerate these rates of dicamba

More information and other control methods

  • For treatment in cereals only apply at 300mL (500g/L) + 1L/ha of 500g/L MCPA.
  • A spraying permit required if treating within 5km of a commercial vineyard or tomato garden.

Herbicide: Bromoxynil + MCPA (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

200g/L bromoxynil (Group C) + 200g/L MCPA (Group I)

Amount of product/10L water

20mL

Rate of product/ha

2L

Time of application

Plants up to six leaves, but not more than 5cm diameter

Remarks

Apply to cereal crops and grass pastures. A spraying permit required if treating within 5km of a commercial vineyard or tomato garden.

Herbicide: Paraquat + diquat (Group L) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

135g/L paraquat + 115g/L diquat

Rate of product/ha

1.1-2.4L

Wetting agent dilution

1:400

Time of application

Seedlings up to two months old and also at flowering to prevent seed set

Remarks

  • Use only in conjunction with a cultivation in preparation for a crop.
  • This chemical should only be used by a person qualifies/trained to apply herbicides.

More information and other control methods

For larger plants water volumes should increase from 50-100L/ha to 150-200L/ha. This product or paraquat (Gramoxone) alone at 2L/ha is very effective in reducing seed production if applied at early flowering. This treatment can also be applied using a wiper. For wiping a mixture of 1L/5L water.

Herbicide: Clopyralid + MCPA (Group I) (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

300g/L or 750g/kg clopyralid  + 500g/L MCPA

Rate of product/ha

50-70mL or 20g clopyralid + 1-1.5L MCPA or 100mL or 40g of clopyralid alone

Time of application

Rosettes prior to stem elongation, while actively growing

Remarks

Clopyralid at 100mL/ha is only effective if applied to weed in summer/autumn after germination of the thistle and before any clover and medics have germinated. Lightly graze pastures to reduce pasture cover. Treat four days after removing stock. Do not graze for at least 15 days.

More information and other control methods

Tordon 242 also registered for variegated thistle, but this is residual and can reduce clover for at least one year

Herbicide: Glyphosate + 2,4-D ester (various trade names: see APVMA link)

Active ingredient

360g/L glyphosate (Group M) + 600, 680g/L 2,4-D LV ester (Group I)

Other concentrations of glyphosate available

Rate of product/ha

400mL glyphosate + 400mL of 2,4-D LV ester
Adjust rates if using another concentrations of glyphosate

Time of application

At flowering

Remarks

Not recommended for south west Western Australia because of risk to commercial vines and vegetables. An APVMA permit is required to apply 2,4-D ester (80%) from 1 September until 1 May.

More information and other control methods

Other formulations of glyphosate available

Contact information

Pest and Disease Information Service (PaDIS)
+61 (0)8 9368 3080